I think maybe I will take a few minutes just to to say something that
I find repulsive about especially monotheistic messianic religion.
With a large part of itself, it quite clearly wants us all to die. It
wants this world to come to an end. You can tell the yearning for
things to be over whenever you read any of its real texts or listen to
any of its real, authentic spokesmen not the sort of pathetic
apologists who sometimes masquerade for it. Those who talk – there was
a famous spokesman for this in Virginia until recently – about the
rapture, say that those of us who have chosen rightly will be gathered
to the arms of Jesus, leaving all of the rest of you behind. If we’re
in a car it’s your lookout, that car won’t have a driver anymore. If
we’re a pilot, that’s your lookout, that plane will crash _we_ will be
with Jesus and the rest of you can go straight to hell.
The escatological element that is _inseparable_ from christianity: if
you don’t believe that there is to be an apocalypse, that there is
going to be an end, a separation of the sheep and the goats, a
condemnation, a final one, then you’re not really a believer, and the
contempt for the things of this world shows through all of them. It’s
well put in an old rhyme from an english exclusive brethren sect that
says that
We are the pure and chosen few
and all the rest are damned.
There’s room enough in hell for you;
we don’t want heaven crammed.
You can tell it when you see the extreme muslims talk. They cannot
wait. They cannot wait for death and destruction to overtake and
overwhelm the world. They can’t wait for what I would call without
ambiguity a _final_ solution. When you look at the Israeli settlers,
paid for often by American tax dollars, deciding if they can steal
enough land from other people and get all the Jews into the promised
land and all the non-Jews out of it, then _finally_ the Jewish people
will be worthy of the return of the messiah. And there are Christians
in this country who consider it their job to help this happen, so that
Armageddon can occur, so that the painful business of living as humans
and studying civilisation and trying to acquire learning and knowledge
and health and medicine, and to push back the frontiers, can all be
scrapped, and the cult of death can take over. That to me is a
hideous thing in escatological terms, in end times terms on it’s own -
a hateful idea, a hateful practice and a hateful theory, but very much
to be opposed in our daily lives where there are people who
_sincerely_ mean it – who want to ruin the good relations that could
exist between different peoples, nations, races, countries, tribes,
ethnicities, who say, who openly say they love death more than we love
life and who are betting that with God on their side, they’re right
about that.
So when I say as the subtitle of my book that I think that religion
poisons _everything_, I’m not just doing what publishers like and
coming up with a provocative subtitle. I mean to say it _infects_ us
in our most _basic_ integrity. It says we can’t be moral without big
brother, without a totalitarian permission. It means we can’t be good
to one another without this. We must be afraid. We must also be
forced to love someone who we fear, The essence of sadomasochism, the
essence of abjection, the essence of the master slave relationship,
and that knows that death is coming and can’t wait to bring it on. I
say this is evil.
And though I do some nights stay home, I enjoy more the nights when I
go out and fight against this ultimate wickedness and ultimate
stupidity.
###
From a debate “Does God Exist?” between Frank Turek and Christopher
Hitchens at Virginia Commonwealth University, September 9, 2008,
hosted by the United Secular Alliance at VCU.
###
Note that I manually transcribed this from youtube, I have
no idea if I’m violating copyright. I did type everything at
least. GD
Posted by gdgd